Horses

Forums
Horse Show Riders Dismounted Based on Weight
 By Saferaphus   •   3rd Nov 2016   •   984 views   •   6 comments


Riders at the 2016 Horse of the Year show were judged on more than their riding skills or their horse’s conformation. Judges and officials called out anyone they deemed to be too large for the size of the horse they are riding. Competitors attending the 2016 HOYS were informed that they would be judged on ‘suitability’. Under new rules, if a rider is thought to be too large for the horse or pony they are on, they will be asked to dismount. Veterinarians, stewards, and officials have the authority to ask a rider to dismount, whether they are in the show ring, warm-up areas or anywhere else on the grounds at any time during the show - even before or after the show begins.

Why this move by HOYS? It’s all part of a push to ensure the humane treatment of horses. Using the guideline of 20% of the horse’s bodyweight, show organizers are hoping to prevent riders who are too heavy for their horses to comfortably carry from riding an unsuitable horse. How is this determined? If any official saw a rider who they felt may be too large for their mount, they were asked to dismount. On the grounds a scale for both horse and rider was used if the rider disputed the judgment.

At a another show last summer, eight people were asked to dismount, all of them adults schooling children’s ponies. But, adults riding ponies before the kids mount up is not really the driving force behind the rules although many claim it is. Many feel overweight riders are an obvious welfare issue.

Now you get to read what I think of this. The issue of kids’ ponies being schooled by adults and competitors riding horses that can’t comfortably carry them are two different things and should be approached differently. Ponies being shown at the level these shows are, shouldn’t need tuning up by an adult at the show. If it’s a good pony, it should be suitable for the child riding it, and not need to be tuned up by an adult. There are shows that have rules that are effective to prevent this already. Why reinvent the wheel? Do what they are doing.

I think an overall ‘awareness’ education program would be more effective to tackle the problem of heavier riders stressing horses that aren’t suitable. If this is truly a common horse welfare concern, it is probably a bigger problem in backyards and small shows than it is in high profile shows like HOYS.

And are a few ‘overweight riders’ a bigger welfare issue than something like poorly fitting saddles? Even skinny, super athletic riders can be riding in a saddle that can damage their horse’s back. In the spirit of horse welfare, isn’t this a more pressing issue? And, the most petite rider can be a burden on their horse’s back depending on how they ride.

So what is at play here? The weight ratio of horse and rider can certainly be an issue. But, maybe it’s only an issue that’s being tackled because when it does occur, it’s very obvious. Poorly fitting saddles, horses with sore mouths because their teeth haven’t been looked after, horses with ulcers because they are stressed - things like those may well be more serious horse welfare concerns - but no one is pointing those out. They’re not obvious. But the ‘weight' of the rider depends on a lot of things - the horse’s build and rider skill for example. It’s just easier to ‘shame’ someone that doesn’t fit a guideline that is only a guideline and not a hard and fast rule. What do you think?
Horse News More In This Category:  Shows and Events      Horse News More From This Author:  Saferaphus
Valkyrie  MOD online
I think it's pretty sensible. It's one thing for a horse to tow a heavy load, but a heavy weight directly on its back (especially if the rider can't ride well) would be detrimental to the horse's health.
  Nov 4, 2016  •  997 views
 
pending sale 2017  
I approve of this 100%!

At home if my childs pony was playing up I would get on it to sort out the issue, but only if I felt the pony could carry me. Fortunate for me am a small ish rider so have always got away with ponys. xD
  Nov 4, 2016  •  992 views
 
Valkyrie  MOD online
Pug: I'm 5'10" so I haven't tried riding ponies since I was about 10 lol
  Nov 5, 2016  •  969 views
 
pending sale 2017  
Am 5ft1 haha the only thing that lets me down now is baby belly I sti llhave! Must loose that xD
  Nov 6, 2016  •  961 views
 
TC Pony Power
I agree with you! This is totally fair I mean look at all those teenagers on exmors and dartmoors in HOYS picture's last year!

(This lady is using cowboy style spurs for starters which aren't allowed in this country (england) anymore, and that poor shetland clearly isnt enjoying it! And also she is not holding her reins propally either! Sorry, I am very picky, I know!)

Now i class myself being too tall for shetlies! And I am only ten.
  Nov 7, 2016  •  937 views
 
Pastel  
I think you really need to research your topic before you upload video footage.
As I've said on the forum, admin should be checking content.
That video is isn't showing what you think it is.
  Nov 9, 2016  •  914 views
 More News by Saferaphus
Bad Horse Bedding and Floor Choices
23rd May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
There are a few things you don’t want under your horse when it’s standing in its stall. If you’re using wood shavings, you will want to be sure that the mix of wood doesn’t include some types of trees. Black walnut shavings contai ...
The Horse Funnies
20th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
I don’t often buy a weekend paper anymore. But when I do, the first section I flip to are the funnies. I love the Peanuts, Family Circus and Sherman’s Lagoon. I also like GoComics on my tablet. Horse magazines don’t have a pull ou ...
Organizing My Tackroom
19th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
Getting your tack room organized and keeping it organized can be a challenge, especially if like many of us you have a lot of ‘stuff’ and only a small space to stash it in. We can dream about the perfectly appointed tack room, fil ...
Talented Artistic Horses
17th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
An ex-racehorse named Metro has contributed to its own life-prolonging treatments by becoming a professional artist. After noticing the horse liked to nod its head, his owner decided to put the habit to use. He taught the horse to ...
How Horse Crazy Are You
13th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
Are you horse crazy? How horse crazy: a little bit, or 100% obsessive? Some of like horses, while others can’t imagine even thinking about anything but. Take this quiz and find out just how horse crazy you really are. ...
Types of Horse Tack Leather Explained
11th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
I was flipping through a mail order tack catalog and noticed the wide range of prices for bridles, saddles and other gear made from leather. Comparing prices, you can buy leather tack for little more than the cost of synthetic tac ...
Equine Harmful Genetic Mutations
9th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
Scientists have examined ancient horse DNA and discovered that horses were once much more genetically diverse than they are now. Domestication may have preserved horses from extinction, but the downside for the modern domestic hor ...
Benefits of Horseback Riding
8th May 2017   |   Shows and Events   |   Saferaphus
I recently read a story from a local newspaper about a girl who, after losing both legs in a car accident, took up riding again. Her parents were uncomfortable with the idea and still frightened each time she gets on her horse. Bu ...
  View All News by Saferaphus
 
Active News Discussions
Problems With Shoes
1
comments
Problems With Shoes
Error 404 - Finances Not Found
1
comments
Error 404 - Finances Not Found
April 20th 2013 Showjumping Competition With Bronze
3
comments
April 20th 2013 Showjumping Competition With Bronze
Rider Dragged by Horse
1
comments
Rider Dragged by Horse
What You Need to Know Before Giving Your Horse Away
2
comments
What You Need to Know Before Giving Your Horse Away
Horse Predator Attacks
2
comments
Horse Predator Attacks
Top Twenty Reasons To Ride A Horse
6
comments
Top Twenty Reasons To Ride A Horse
Attack of the Pasture Burrs
1
comments
Attack of the Pasture Burrs
Slim Chance of Horse Twins Surviving
1
comments
Slim Chance of Horse Twins Surviving
What You Need to Know Before Giving Your Horse Away
2
comments
What You Need to Know Before Giving Your Horse Away
 
©2002 - 2017   PonyBox LLC Create Account Terms & Conditions Privacy Contact Us
318 Members Online 236,642 Registered Members 2,283 News Articles 9,064,078 Unique News Article Views 194,775,053 Website Views