For Sale

Forums

Photos

Politics
 
Is Barbed Wire Fencing Safe For Horse Pastures?
 By Valkyrie   •   22nd Oct 2011   •   9,971 views   •   30 comments
Barbed WireRecently I’ve seen a lot of members who have formed a lynch mob and are going around sneering at and jeering other members who have barbed wire fencing. This is immature and heavy-handed behaviour. I myself was a victim of one of these members and did not appreciate their holier-than-thou attitude. I have no choice in the fence they were berating me about. That fence is there for safety reasons (my neighbour owns young bulls, which are extremely unpredictable). That is the ONLY barbed wire fence on my property (the rest are all wood or wood and mesh).

Yes, barbed wire is bad for horses if the horse becomes tangled. But horses only become tangled if loose sands are left to coil on the ground or the wires are loose. In many cases barbed wire is a lot safer than simple wire, as the horses soon learn the barbs are sharp and uncomfortable and will avoid it, whereas normal wire teaches them nothing. I once had normal wire fence for my Standardbred and she would lean over it and into it all the time, cutting her neck and chest. When we moved her to our current property she left the boundary fence alone once she realised it wasn’t comfortable to touch it.

Wood wouldn’t work with that horse, either. She broke a wooden fence leaning into it. It was a brand new fence, built by my father who was a builder for many years in his youth. It wasn’t rotting, or loose, or shoddily put together like the lovers of wooden fences state about accidents concerning them. She was simply too heavy and didn’t respect it. The way it snapped I’m lucky she didn’t impale herself.

The truth is, some types of fencing won’t work for some horses. My friend once had a horse who cunningly used her cover to lean on electric fences so she wouldn’t get shocked. That same friend had a miniature horse with a penchant for jumping wooden fences but wouldn’t go near a wire one. I know horses who’ve cribbed wooden ones and have to be paddocked with a wire fence to protect their teeth. And yet others who don’t respect wire and have to be paddocked with wooden. I’ve seen horses in deer fencing, or with stone walls, or with hedges. There are many types of fencing. It’s what works for your horse in your situation that matters, not what a bunch of do-gooders think.

Every fencing is dangerous. If horses get a fright they are going to run into the fence no matter what type it is. They aren’t going to slam on the brakes and think ‘oh wait, it’s wood, my master says that’s really safe so I shouldn’t break it.’ And they aren’t going to speed up going ‘wire! Must... get... tangled! Must kill myself!’

It is expensive to replace fencing, and a lot of us are young and have to rely on our parents, or board our horses somewhere. And if they say ‘no’ to changing fencing because it costs too much then don’t worry, it’s not your fault. The ignorant people on here shouldn’t be calling you lazy and irresponsible, especially if they don’t know your situation. Often we don’t have a choice in what our horses are fenced in.

If you don’t have a choice in your fencing, then there are ways to make barbed wire as safe as possible.

1. Like any wire, barbed can be invisible to horses at night, so if you can, get a fluorescent wire or tape and run it around the perimeter, or tie bits of it at frequent intervals.

2. Keep the wire taunt so that sagging bits won’t catch your horse.

3. Replace any rusty bits and do a perimeter check often to make sure there are no loose wires.

4. Use as many strands as possible to make a proper boundary and so your horse won’t think of ducking under it or jumping it.

5. Tie coloured tape to the top wires so the horse can see the wire is there.

My barbed wire fence (the boundary) has many little posts spaced along it at half-metre intervals. It helps my girls recognise that there are no gaps to run through. If possible, stable or yard your horses at night. Nighttime is when the fence will be most invisible.

6. Wrap your horse’s legs and put a cover on them when they are in the paddock. If they do somehow get tangled the damage will be less, if at all.

7. Run an electric wire or tape along the inside of the fence and keep it hot all the time, your horses will avoid it, especially if the electric fence ticks loudly.

Barbed wire can be used to successfully and painlessly keep a horse, despite what others on this site may think. Here in New Zealand we do not have fancy barns and stables everywhere with white wooden fences and pretty stone walls. Sure, there are places like this around, mostly professional stud farms. But a lot of our horses are kept on cattle properties by hobby riders, which are more often than not fenced with barbed wire. But the owners of the horses and cattle aren’t “stupid” or “lazy” or “irresponsible.” They check boundaries constantly and do fence maintenance where necessary. I should know, my parents used to dairy farm and my dad is now a farm consultant. I have never seen any accidents in all my 19 years involving barbed wire. It doesn’t mean I won’t see any, and it certainly doesn’t mean barbed wire is safe beyond a doubt. But when properly taken care of barbed wire isn’t the devil.

It all comes down to knowing your horse. If your horse doesn’t respect wire fencing, then by all means keep them in wooden fencing. If they run around and get silly and don’t think, then keep them in safer fencing. But if they’re smart and respect wire then there is no reason why barbed wire can’t be used to contain them.

At the end of the day, if a horse is going to get hurt on a fence it doesn’t matter what kind of fence it is they run into, they’re still going to get hurt. It’s up to us to make sure they respect fences, no matter what kind.

I do not condone barbed wire usage. I’m not saying everyone should go out and use it and that it’s okay and safe. I’m saying that anything with horses can be dangerous, but there are ways to make it safer if we can’t afford to replace it.
Horse News More PB Articles About:  Fence,  Barbed,
Horse News More In This Category:  General      Horse News More From This Author:  Valkyrie
T W I  
While I believe that barbed wire can definitely pose a safety hazard, I agree with you that in certain situations, it is the best alternative.
Sounds like you were one of those situations and I'm sorry to hear that people were ganging up on you about it.
  Oct 22, 2011  •  3,058 views
 
Spyricale  
And here we go....people who support bad horsemanship and all around dangerous fencing. If you're going to be cheap, don't own horses. Simple.

Barbed wire is dangerous. Dangerous. Dangerous. (Just in case you didn't see the first "dangerous".)

Soooo...here we go again.

"I have heard a LOT of excuses for still having horses out on barbed wire:

One. My horses are “smart” and don’t go near the fence.
Two. My horses have never been hurt on it.
Three. We have too much acreage to change the fence.
Four. It’s only temporary until I find another place to board.
Five. It’s the only place I can afford to keep my horses.
Six. I rent and they won’t let me change the fence.
Seven. The horses are out with the cows so we have to have barbed wire.
Eight.But everyone in my area has their horses out on barbed wire!

I have heard it all. You are not going to come up with a new excuse, trust me. Not a single one of these excuses is valid. If you own a thousand acres, fen
  Oct 22, 2011  •  4,371 views
 
FreeRein  
uh, It is kind of still bad... no matter how many saftey precaustions there are there is always that one in a million chance...
  Oct 22, 2011  •  2,996 views
 
All That Jazz  online
I've never liked barbed wire, and personally won't ever use it, but I do like how you had safety precautions and whatnot in your article. :)
  Oct 22, 2011  •  4,374 views
 
SMFponies  
Okay here's my opinion. Barbed wire is definately a no-no at a high performace barn for two reasons.
1) is capable of ripping up horses and giving them cosmetic scars that decrease the value of a horse. Resulting in them not being able to show as well or sell as well.I used to have barbed wire until it cut one of my horses. Every person who comes to look to buy him asks what happend to his leg.

2)Connecting to said above, it is not very pretty and unprofessional.

BUT! when used to fence a massive area it could be way more useful than traditional "white fencing". (fast fact: barbed wire was invented out in the midwest during the cattle runs to keep the herds from trampling/eating crops) As long as the horse is able to see it, its fine by me. But I would advise not putting barbed wire on lower strings where a horse could stick their foot over/under it.

SECONDLY!! PEOPLE STOP TRYING TO PREACH THE HORSEY BIBLE TO EVERYBODY!
Come on guys. POLITELY ask why something is the wa
  Oct 22, 2011  •  4,407 views
 
Madeirey  
I really like this news post and I TOTALLY agree with you!
  Oct 22, 2011  •  4,372 views
 
Que Sara  
Great article Perdedora!!

Hopefully the people that do have to use barbed wire as fencing, or have no choice to will now not have to avoid coming on here in the fear of having pieces vocally torn off them.

I myself have no objections to any type of fencing. If it does it's job of keeping intruders out and the horses in then it is a job well done. No matter what it is constructed of.

I think the same as you and have repeated it several times, by it's very nature, any type of fencing can be classed as hazardous if not used correctly.
  Oct 23, 2011  •  3,009 views
 
Simplicity  
This is a very fair post.
  Oct 23, 2011  •  3,989 views
 
Valkyrie  MOD online
Thankyou to those of you who have disagreed, but have stated your opinions in the comments in a mature fashion.

You are all, of course, correct that barbed wire can be dangerous. And I agree it shouldn't be used around horses. But when properly maintained it can be no more dangerous than any other fence if your horse isn't a silly, highly-strung escape-artist.

A fence is a fence.
  Oct 23, 2011  •  3,998 views
 
GoinGoingGone  
Yes I have to say if you have barb wire fencing in ONLY one part of your farm because of like in your case young bulls yes, but as long as you keep the fence tight and kept up. Oh and even if well kept up horses too are unpredictable and may spook right into the fence so if I were to take sides it would be no. There is no way to prevent a horse from cutting its self unless you are ALWAYS watching it, which I don't think most people do that. Just sit on a chair and watch their horse, and yell STOP when coming near it. And there are MANY economical fencing choices out there!
  Oct 23, 2011  •  4,022 views
 
Eire  
All through cow country in WY and MT the horses are fenced with barbed wire. Most have a cut above their hock or on their forehead, but very few have more than one.

For an operation that just has horses, mostly any wire is a bad idea. In the case of cows, rams and even billies barbed wire is the right decision.

Barbed wire keeps humans safe. Believe me, cows will not always move off a highway. And once you hit one, your car, you and the cow are probably gone.
  Oct 23, 2011  •  5,796 views
 
Unique  
Very good article. I don't care for barbed-wire fencing, but I am not totally against anyone who uses it. This was very needed. Thank you. :3
  Oct 23, 2011  •  3,990 views
 
Dark Star  
No. Barb wire should NEVER be used to keep horses in. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES. No matter the excuse, I have an answer.
1. I board my horse, and they have barb wire fencing. - Move barns.
2. My horse has never been hurt by it - It only takes once to cost your horse a lot.
3. My horse won't go near the fence - Again, It would only take 1 time.
4. We can't afford any other fencing - 2 answers to this - (a.) Fencing is cheaper then vet bills. (b.) If you can't afford adequate fencing, you don't need a horse.

Any other excuses, I have an answer, feel free to test it.

I have seen a very bad thing happen with barb wire fencing. I have found a horse that bled to death cause he was put out in the same barb wire pasture he had been in for 7 years and never been hurt by it, but somehow he got caught in it and he freaked out, ripping himself to pieces, til finally it cut one of his major arteries and he bled to death.

My mare, Dee, was put in a barb wire fence before we had her, and s
  Oct 24, 2011  •  5,364 views
 
Run Free  
i totally agree that every fencing is dangerous but barbed wire is one of the most dangerous. yes sometimes you dont have a choice but try to avoid it when possible. i do understand that some horses dont respect fencing and it is needed to keep them in just make sure it is obvious that it is there to your horses.personally my favourite type of fencing is electric wire but that is quite dangerous too if it has too much or not enough bolts in it!
  Oct 24, 2011  •  4,035 views
 
Spaztastic  
Thanks for writing an article about this. I'm one of those people who really don't have a choice in fencing. It can be dangerous though.
  Oct 24, 2011  •  4,020 views
 
SMFponies  
I agree with Spyricle when they say that this debate is getting us nowhere. I think that its only getting us mad at each other and posting very rude comments. I sincerelly apologize to Spyricle for some nasty words on my end. What I've come to conclude is that Barbed wire can cause serious medical wounds to our equine friends. But some find that it is neccesary in the financial/geological/political situation that they are in. I've devised a pole if any body wants to be humored by it, please vote. I hope fellow Ponyboxers will join me in not judging you by your vote
-Thanks a lot
  Oct 24, 2011  •  4,026 views
 
City on the Hill  
A fence. You people are fighting over a fence. And just to be annoying I shall join the argument. No, I don't own horses, but my friend does. Three sides of my friends pasture is a wood fence, and one side is barbed wire. They couldn't afford to replace it all, so they did as much as they could. We have wild dogs and coyotes in our area, and middle of winter one of them chased one of their horses straight into the wood fence. It KILLED the horse. The coyote ran off when my friends dad came outside, but shards off the wood stuck into the horse and it bled out before the vet could get there.

One year later, same thing happens, but through the barbed wire. That horse came away with less damage, and barely any scars.

My point? It can happen on any fence, and what people use is their business, so stop ganging up on them. I myself have run straight into newly put up barbed wire, and to be honest, it wasn't that bad. The key is not to let your horse panic, just cut the wire and get th
  Oct 25, 2011  •  5,559 views
 
lovehorse  
Life is risky-there are no certainties....At the end of the day the significant factor centers around personal'Responsibility'......
  Oct 28, 2011  •  5,363 views
 
Dream Forever  
I have read most of these comments............... I am very disappointed as I tought you were all more mature than that............... Honestly,yes,barbed wire shouldn't be used........ But this article was posted for people who were giving out about it but some people have no say about what wire or fencing is used......... Opinions are opinions bur if they are going to be as immature as this.............. PLEASE DON'T POST THEM...........
  Oct 28, 2011  •  5,411 views
 
silentgirl  
Great story...

Yes barbwire can be dangerous to horses to a point, so can any type of panel,fencing or means of material you decide to use to keep your horses or live stock in. Just because someone uses barbwire to fence to keep their horses in doesn't make them a bad horse owner or person. I have personally known a couple of people who have owned or still own horses to this day who use barbed wire to keep their horses on their property.

A old family friend of ours who was well known in different horse circuits from rodeo,cutting,paint horse breeding and the appaloosa association use to have most of her 10 acres surrounded by barb wire fencing to keep her horses in the pastures. She also would have some trees planted too along side the fencing and did this make her a bad horse own or breeder/boarder? Nope not in the least. She took very well care of the horses she owned and the ones that other people boarded on her property.
Her property was like this until she sold it bac
  Nov 1, 2011  •  5,396 views
 
RoyalCrownEstates  MOD 
I like the stricle, great information !

(all the rude comments listed above)

if you dont have something nice to say. Don't say anything at all.. simple
  Nov 3, 2011  •  5,393 views
 
Hoofz  
I respect you for standing up for yourself and other barbed wire users. :)
  Nov 7, 2011  •  5,484 views
 
SftbllGrl18  
no i don't think it's safe my uncle had a horse that got CAUGHT IN IT AND HE ALMOST DIED. but there is a kind that dosen't have the spikes that I would reccommend
  Nov 12, 2011  •  5,387 views
 
Empathy  
You guys are slightly overreacting, evreyone has diffrent oppinones and so please respect that. Pb is not for arguing. I don't mean to affend anyone. And its not my place to speak, but still. :)
  Nov 17, 2011  •  5,368 views
  1  2    
 More News by Valkyrie
The Life and Times of the Infamous Banna Strand   26th Jul 2013   •   590 views
The Life and Times of the Infamous Banna Strand The incident that occurred on the fifth of May, 2011, may be New Zealand Thoroughbred gelding Banna Strand's only claim to fame. By the Danehill son Danasinga, out of a Kaapstad mare, Banna Strand (2003) was trained by John Wheeler and had an unsuccessful flat racing career, never breaking his maiden in over thirty starts, before making the transition to ste . . .
 
Horse Lineart Tutorial Basics   26th Apr 2012   •   4734 views
Horse Lineart Tutorial Basics This is a very basic tutorial. A lot of artists go into more depth with their work, and I often like to as well, but for the purpose of learning and gaining confidence I've just whipped up a quick tutorial to get you started. There are plenty of tutorials on sites like DeviantART if you want to go further. But for the sake of time, and my sanity, here's some . . .
 
Kia Kaha - Who Dares Wins   6th Aug 2011   •   2167 views
Kia Kaha - Who Dares Wins School! Claire groaned and dived into the car. And not just any school – PUBLIC SCHOOL. For the past three years she had been attending a private all girls boarding school six hours away. This year Gloria had finally relented and allowed her to attend school closer to home so that Claire could still work at the stables. But Claire had completely forgotten to . . .
 
Mark Toddy Todd - The Equestrian Comeback kid   22nd Jun 2011   •   2901 views
Mark Toddy Todd - The Equestrian Comeback kid He may just be history's biggest comeback kid – ever. Mark (“Toddy”) Todd recently became the oldest person to ever win the prestigious Badminton Horse Trials at the ripe old age of 55, beating previous record-holder Andrew Hoy by eight years. Winner of two consecutive individual gold medals in Olympic eventing (aboard the same horse – Charisma) Toddy ret . . .
 
Daddy Is The World Coming To An End?   13th Mar 2011   •   3178 views
Daddy Is The World Coming To An End? As I write this it is Saturday, four days after the disaster. Nobody has been pulled alive from the wreckage since Wednesday afternoon. The death toll stands at 123 as of this morning, with 228 missing. Most of whom are trapped inside the Canterbury TV building where it is believed the bodies of 100 staff and international language students remain trapped. . . .
 
Armistice Day - November 11th   11th Nov 2010   •   4529 views
Armistice Day - November 11th Countless men and women died for your freedom. The least you can do them is pay the courtesy of remembering their sacrifice this Armistice Day November 11th. I will. . . .
 
New Zealand Horse Racing - Par Xcellence   30th Sep 2010   •   3321 views
New Zealand Horse Racing - Par Xcellence The announcer's voice boomed from the speakers over the course as the nine-strong field of the 2007 Sir James Fletcher Stakes thundered down the Ellerslie straight. As he spat out the names of the frontrunners, a large bay at the back of the pack caught his eye. . . .
 
Free to Use Horse Images   13th Sep 2010   •   4937 views
Free to Use Horse Images I was getting so astronomically sick and tired of finding stolen Google images here on Ponybox and having to report them, that I have decided to try combat it by offering free horse images that members can use as-is. . . .
 
  View All News by Valkyrie
Trick Training - Teach Your Horse to Bow Every little girl has a dream. To be swept off her feet by a charming knight in shining armour on a big white horse, and have him kneel down before her, take her hand, kiss her cheek, and whatever other secret, romantic . . .
Crazy Stunts with Olop - Jumping Backwards - Part 2 Let me begin with a note to any of you who scorn this idea: I first got this idea from seeing a photo of Rodrgio Pessoa, an undeniably brilliant rider, trying the exact same stunt: Jumping his horse backwards. It isn’t j . . .
Saddle Up Series - Understanding Your Horse's Back - Part Four As mentioned before, back pain in horses is shockingly common; in fact most horses – even the soundest of them – are likely to be experiencing at least a small degree of back pain simply from the strain of hard work. The . . .
Retraining A Racehorse – Moonfire – Cross Country - Part 1 On 17 February 2011, I began preparing Moony for his eventing debut. After his Third Place in his first jumping show of the year, I decided it was time for him to start eventing and see if he couldn’t achieve similar res . . .
The Bit Dictionary - Mouthpieces - Part 3 of 3 This part of ‘The Bit Dictionary’ explores numerous common mouthpieces found in snaffle bits. Finding the correct mouthpiece, along with the correct action, is of the utmost importance to the horse’s comfort and performa . . .
Cross Country 101 - Part Three A trakehner is a type of cross country jump consisting of a pole suspended over a ditch. These jumps often prove a huge problem, especially for up and coming eventers, simply because of the intimidating nature of the fen . . .
Saddle Up Series - Understanding Your Horse's Back - Part Two Believe it or not, an ill-fitting saddle is not the only cause of back pain in horses, although it is the leading one. Back pain can be caused by a number of different things. The following are a few prime examples. A ri . . .
Crazy Stunts with Olop - Jumping Backwards - Part 1 Who is Olop, you ask? Well, that is my new nickname for Polo. Read on, and I daresay the reason will soon become clear. Those of you who know me will surely know that I am somewhat ‘lacking’ in the sanity division. In . . .
Retraining A Racehorse – Moonfire – Cross Country - Part 2 On 26 February 2011, there was an open day at one of the nicest show venues in the Province, and also one of the few that is never available to rent for public use – it is used for shows only, as is the rule. Thus, it wa . . .
Pelham Ponies - Yay or Neigh At every show, without fail, we will see some tiny kid chucked up on the million dollar showjumping pony that Daddy dearest smashed his piggy bank to buy, and 9 out of ten times, little Sally or Mary-Sue will be sitting . . .
 
©2002 - 2014  -  PonyBox LLC Create Account Terms & Conditions Privacy Contact Us Moderators Online Now
175 PonyBox members online