Items

Forums
Is it Time To End Horse Drawn Carriages in New York City
 By Winniefield Park   •   29th Jan 2014   •   3,750 views   •   1 comments
I've had to spend some time in the city lately, and I can't say I've particularly enjoyed the experience. With its crowded sidewalks, bumper-to-bumper traffic, car exhaust and strange smells, potholes and streetcar tracks, flashing lights, waving signs and noise, noise, noise. The city can be a very stressful place to navigate. Imagine dealing with all of these things when you're a horse.



There was a time when the horse-drawn vehicle was one of the very few ways to get around in the city. Old photographs depict a time when the traffic jams were entirely of horse-drawn buggies, freight wagons, trolleys and carts. Now some horses vie with cars, streetcars, buses and transport trucks for the right of way. These horses pull carriages containing tourists. While many regard this as a romantic tradition, animal activists and horse lovers everywhere are looking closely at the carriage-horse industry, and many have decided that city streets are no place for a horse.

Related: Should Police Horses Be Banned
Related: Paraguay Bans Work Horses in City Streets After Outcry From Animal Rights Groups

One of the more noisy debates is going on in New York city. Here, horse-drawn carriages can be hired for tours through Central Park and other tourist attractions. The mayor of New York, Bill de Blasio has decided that it's time to end the tradition. He and many other New York residents have decided that horses working long shifts, in crowded streets, trodding on unyielding pavement in all weather is unacceptable. It's a move the ASPC agrees with, stating that it is “unnatural, unnecessary, and an undeniable strain on the horses’ quality of life.”

It's not just the horses that are the issue. Public safety is risked when carriage horses are hit or spooked. There are many documented accidents where people (and horses) have been harmed or killed. Many people think that horses travelling on city streets presents an unnecessary risk.

Others disagree. Long time New York carriage owners point out that the stables, and the working conditions are subject to strict regulation. In 2010, the Carriage Operators of North America invited Harry Werner, former head of the American Association of Equine Practitioners to inspect the horse's living conditions. Werner found nothing objectionable. Horses are given regular rest times and veterinary check ups, as well as five weeks in pasture out of the city. Carriage operators point out that there have been relatively few accidents. Those who don't want to see the carriage industry shut down argue that these horses, now without jobs, will end up abandoned, or on trucks headed for the processing plants of Canada or Mexico. Humans will lose jobs too.

The proposed solution for New York City is to replace the horses with antique style electric cars. But, will tourists find them as alluring? And, if the horses disappear from NYC, will it be a precedent-setting move that will be followed in other cities? Horse-drawn carriages have been banned in a number of cities already, including London, Paris, Toronto, Palm Beach, and Beijing. Animal rights groups are seeking bans in several other cities such as Sacramento, Niagara Falls and Salt Lake City.

Should carriage rides through city streets be banned? Is this cruelty to horses?

Horse News More PB Articles About:  carriage,
Horse News More In This Category:  Horse Rescue and Abuse      Horse News More From This Author:  Winniefield Park
GrayceRomeo  
Terrible People!
  Jan 31, 2014  •  4,123 views
 Related Horse News
Is it Time To End Horse Drawn Carriages in New York City
29th Jan 2014   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
I've had to spend some time in the city lately, and I can't say I've particularly enjoyed the experience. With its crowded sidewalks, bumper-to-bumper traffic, car exhaust and strange smells, potholes and streetcar tracks, flashin ...
Looking at the Arguments Against the Carriage Trade
5th Jun 2016   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
While I fundamentally agree that the time for the carriage trade in its present form is past, some of the arguments you see online against it don’t make sense.The public often doesn’t see horses in the same way ‘horse people’ do, ...
Horse Carriage Trade Update
7th Jun 2017   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
In Montreal, Canada, calls to end the carriage trade within the city have intensified. Two incidents during the first long weekend of the summer. In one, a horse fell, requiring the assistance of onlookers and a veterinarian to he ...
Victoria BC Horse Carriage Ban
22nd Jun 2018   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
The rumblings about the carriage trade in Victoria have been ongoing for some time now. An incident last May has brought the business under harder scrutiny. Earlier this spring, two horses pulling a carriage fell on the street. A ...
Horse Collapses at Sugar Shack Wagon Ride
25th Apr 2019   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Animal activists cry foul as video of a horse pulling a wagon load of tourists enjoying a day at a maple sugar bush fell. The Montreal SPCA is investigating and the contractor who ran the wagon ride at the sugar bush has suspende ...
Savannah Carriage Rides in Extreme Heat
5th Jun 2019   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Like so many other cities and tourist areas around the world, Savannah, Georgia is grappling with issues surrounding carriage horses. Even in the hottest days of summer, Savannah’s three carriage operators give tours through histo ...
Another Caleche Horse Collapses Weeks Before Ban
9th Nov 2019   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Calčche horses in the city of Montreal are again in the focus of animal rights activists. This time a horse slipped as it crossed a metal plate and ended up lying on its side in the street. Although the police found no abuse of th ...
Montreal Carriage Rides End
26th Jan 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
After years of controversy the city of Montreal, Quebec, caleches, the quaint carriage rides through the historic city are banned as of January 1, 2020. The tourist districts will no longer hear the familiar clip clop of hooves as ...
Istanbul Tourist Carriage Horses In Dire Condition
9th Feb 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
It often seems that tourism and horses is an unfortunate mix, especially when the offerings go unregulated. Such is the case in Istanbul, where carriage rides have come under scrutiny. Combined with a deadly virual outbreak, Istan ...
  View More PonyBox Related Horse Articles
 More News by Winniefield Park
Top 5 PonyBox Jumpers
4th Apr 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
It may be winter in the Northern Hemisphere but show season never slows down on Ponybox. Several horses have topped the 100” mark in jump offs. Here’s a look at the top five highest jumpers on Ponybox right now. ...
Rescued Horses Had To Be Dug Out of Stalls
1st Apr 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Animal rescuers in Massassachettes had to dig two horses out of their stalls after they discovered a horrific case of neglect. The two horses had sores on their back from rubbing on the rafters of their stalls because the manure w ...
Horse Diagnosed with COVID-19 In Arizona
30th Mar 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Covid19, the new coronavirus that has turned into a global pandemic is affecting almost everything and certainly dominating the news. It’s likely to be that way for weeks, and possibly months to come. Coronaviruses take up residen ...
Awkward Wedding Proposal
24th Mar 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
It’s always fun to see unusual marriage proposals. But some special moments shouldn’t be upstaged by a horse. Recently, a horse took center stage in a carefully planned proposal. She said yes, but with the horse taking nibbles at ...
PonyBox Oldest Barns
22nd Mar 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
The Ponybox game foaled in 2001 and since then there have been a lot of changes. Servers have crashed, the rules have evolved. And many of the oldest barns have disappeared, or morphed into newer establishments as the game has cha ...
Wild Horses In Reno Streets
21st Mar 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
You’d expect to have to head out into the wilderness to observe wild horses. But that isn’t the case in Reno, Nevada. In fact, it’s not unusual to see horses wandering through Reno neighborhoods and the streets of other nearby tow ...
Horse Autism Therapy For Kids
20th Mar 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
A new study suggests that kids with autism and ADHD may benefit from horseback riding lessons. Not only does riding help with motor function, strength, flexibility and dexterity, researchers also felt that that participants in the ...
Horses Are Weird
17th Mar 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Horses are weird! Yes they are. They walk around on one finger, have few if any close relatives and as a species, have taken a strange circuitous route from North America and back again. Vloggers Hank and John, who call themselves ...
  View All News by Winniefield Park
 
©2002 - 2020   PonyBox LLC Create Account Terms & Conditions Privacy Contact Us
298 Members Online 263,161 Registered Members 2,687 News Articles 11,429,874 Unique News Article Views 271,809,189 Website Views