Items

Forums
Should Police Horses Be Banned
 By Winniefield Park   •   5th May 2014   •   3,743 views   •   3 comments
Should Police Horses Be Banned

The debates over whether horse-drawn carriages should be used on NYC streets continue. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, who promised to have the carriages shut down has now softened his stance after a carefully planned campaign, in which Liam Neelson has taken a starring role, to keep the carriages going was launched. In addition to his star-studded opposition, labor unions began pressuring de Blasio to protect the jobs of the carriage drivers, and the profit that carriage rides bring in.

Even the New York State Horse Council, with the backing of the American Horse Council is speaking out to save the city’s carriage industry. After inspecting the stables two months ago, the NYSHC stated that the carriage horse housing was some of the best they have seen. In a statement of support, they claim that the carriage horses were an icon of NYC, and that they are not in any way treated inhumanely.

“It is the opinion of the Board of Directors of the New York State Horse Council that the NYC carriage horses, and their owners should be allowed to continue to operate their small businesses without fear of reprisal or loss of livelihood.”

Related: Is it Time To End Horse Drawn Carriages in New York City
Related: Paraguay Bans Work Horses in City Streets After Outcry From Animal Rights Groups

With his vow to banish the carriage trade de Blasio may have backed himself into a bit of a corner, claiming that while the carriage industry is bad for horses, police work is not. Police horses, claim de Blasio, provide an essential service, not just entertainment for tourists. The work police horses do, including patrolling city streets and crowd control is far more beneficial to the public than a ride through Central Park, or touring to see the sights.

However, there are those who argue that horses that pull carriages and horses that do police work should be measured with the same stick. Police horses often face more hectic streets and high pressure situations then the carriage horse, and are therefore exposed to the same environment and greater challenges. If carriage horses go, so should police horses.

However, those who feel police work differs from carriage pulling argue that police horses live in a state-of-the-art stable, and get daily turnout in addition to a planned retirement for their golden years. The lives and care of police horses is much different.

If NYC bans carriage horses, should it also ban police horse? What is the difference between the work and the management of carriage and police horses? What do you think?
Horse News More PB Articles About:  Mounted Police,
Horse News More In This Category:  General      Horse News More From This Author:  Winniefield Park
Velski  
As a person who's met police horses and a few of their riders, I can say the horses are very content. They're specially chosen and trained to deal with the situations they end up in. And-at least where I live-they have an incredible stables. They have constant care available to them.
I don't know much about carriage horses, so I won't go into that.
  May 5, 2014  •  4,506 views
 
Dark Star  
Here is how I see it, if they ban carriage driving and police horses, I see a lot of slaughter trucks and full auctions in the near future. That is all I'm gonna say on that subject.
  May 5, 2014  •  4,498 views
 
Valkyrie  MOD 
I think police horses are in an entirely different situation. The police realise the job is high stress and the horses are well taken care of with frequent holiday time. They are needed for things like crowd control and to placate strained neighbourhoods. An officer on a horse is more maneuverable than one in a car, and can get from A to Z faster than an officer on foot or a bicycle. Police horses are necessary and are exceptionally well cared for. They are also retired long before they become too jaded.

On the flipside carriage horses spend long days in the freezing cold or extreme heat, standing around on hard asphalt and concrete, dragging a heavy cart full of screaming families through noisy and polluted streets. London gave up carriages when motor cars became popular, and for good reason. Carriage horses do not serve a useful function except to provide entertainment for bored tourists. The amount of accidents they cause or are involved in is growing and it is completely unneces
  May 5, 2014  •  4,492 views
 Related Horse News
Should Police Horses Be Banned
5th May 2014   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
The debates over whether horse-drawn carriages should be used on NYC streets continue. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, who promised to have the carriages shut down has now softened his stance after a carefully planned campaign ...
Buy A Police Horse
26th Sep 2018   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
Previously, the RCMP held their auction every other year. But it has been three years since the last auction and about forty horses are being offered. Online bidding has been open since mid-August for the police foundation auction ...
The Mounted Police Horse Debate
26th Aug 2016   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
Whether or not horses should be used in policing is a topic of debate for some. But, right or wrong, horses provide a valuable service when used in police work. While cars, SUVs, ATVs, snowmobiles and other motorized vehicles are ...
Halifax Police Retire Sarge After 13 Years of Service
30th Apr 2019   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
When a police officer retires, there’s usually a ceremony to mark the occasion. After a career of putting your life on the line, you deserve some recognition. So when Duty Sergeant, an eighteen year old Clyde cross, who has been w ...
The Columbus Mounted Police Unit
14th Jul 2019   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
If you’ve ever wondered how mounted police units desensitize their horses to working around crowds in stressful situations, the Columbus Mounted Police unit provides a glimpse into their training process. ...
  View More PonyBox Related Horse Articles
 More News by Winniefield Park
Montreal Carriage Rides End
26th Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
After years of controversy the city of Montreal, Quebec, caleches, the quaint carriage rides through the historic city are banned as of January 1, 2020. The tourist districts will no longer hear the familiar clip clop of hooves as ...
Australian Horse Racing Industry Abuse Response
25th Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
Last fall we posted a story about a news documentary exploring the route from race track to slaughter house in Australia. Jockeys, trainers, owners and others in the industry were shocked by the revelations of cruelty and the ulti ...
Amish Boys Get DUI on Horse and Buggy
23rd Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
four underage Amish men charged with felony obstruction of justice, disorderly conduct and given civil infractions for being minors in possession of alcohol. Witnesses saw the young men tossing beer cans from the buggy. The heavil ...
Top PonyBox Stables To Start 2020
21st Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
2020, and a new decade is only a few weeks old. The winter days seem to drag, it certainly doesn’t seem like the Roaring Twenties, but game play continues with changing stats and rankings. Here’s a look at some of the top barns on ...
Rejected Show Horse Saves Owner from Fire in Australia
19th Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
As her family fled the fire, leaving behind possessions and favorite farm animals, a horse named Charmer, once rejected as a show horse, carried her owner to safety though blinding smoke to safety. Her rider, disoriented by the sm ...
PonyBox Top Fives and Prospects
18th Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
Who has been at the coveted number one ranking recently? Here is a look at some of the horses that have reached the number one spot and a few that are poised to grab top spot very soon. ...
Tiniest Dwarf Horse Learns To Walk
13th Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
Chanel the tiny horse is a dwarf. She had a hard start in life when her mother rejected her. Her poorly formed legs made it difficult to learn to walk and she had to be bottle fed every two hours. Her breeder reached out to the Pe ...
One hundred Horses Rescued In Police Sting Operation
12th Jan 2020   |   General   |   Winniefield Park
A team of volunteers is responsible for rescuing over one hundred horses in King County near Enumclaw. The horses, some in foal and with foals by their sides, were being kept in unsanitary conditions by a women well known to be a ...
  View All News by Winniefield Park
 
©2002 - 2020   PonyBox LLC Create Account Terms & Conditions Privacy Contact Us
434 Members Online 258,827 Registered Members 2,657 News Articles 11,272,315 Unique News Article Views 266,721,936 Website Views