Items

Forums
 
Looking at the Arguments Against the Carriage Trade
 By Winniefield Park   •   5th Jun 2016   •   2,979 views   •   0 comments
Looking at the Arguments Against the Carriage Trade

While I fundamentally agree that the time for the carriage trade in its present form is past, some of the arguments you see online against it donít make sense.The public often doesnít see horses in the same way Ďhorse peopleí do, which can result in some unfortunate misconceptions. Hereís a few Iíve come across lately.

The Horses are Underfed and Dehydrated
One blogger despaired of a carriage horse that was dripping foam from its mouth - surely it was terribly thirsty. These horses, while they may not get water at the exact time they want it are not foaming at the mouth because of dehydration. A horse that is badly dehydrated will not be able to foam - and will quickly develop severe problems. Many horses chew on the bit, a habit which might be a lot like someone who fiddles with their rings, or chews the strings on their hoodie, and that causes the foaming. It may be a bad habit, but it likely isnít overly harmful. Generally, the horse world sees a wet mouth as a good thing.

And, some of these horses may be lean, but most arenít unhealthy looking. Horses are healthier on the lean side and not as prone to obesity related problems like equine metabolic syndrome.

Related: Is it Time To End Horse Drawn Carriages in New York City
Related: Should Police Horses Be Banned
Related: Paraguay Bans Work Horses in City Streets After Outcry From Animal Rights Groups

Horses Have to Wear Tight Bridles With Chains in Their Mouth
A bit, which of which you can only see the outside rings is not a thick chain, and does not cut into the skin in any way. As to their heads being tied down, or their bridles are too tight, that is simply untrue.

Horses Have to Pull Heavy Loads
Those carriages look heavy, and even more so filled with tourists. But, a 1000 lbs on wheels is a small load for a draft horse. It may be tedious work, but weight-wise, it isnít strenuous.

Horses Have Horrible Accidents On City Streets
Horses are involved in accidents on city streets. These get a lot of negative press. But, one of the most common news headlines announcing horses/ traffic accidents include horses used by certain religious sects. These horses pound down the pavement daily, yet few voice concern over their treatment. (If you think they are universally well treated, think again.) The sight of a horse pulling a buggy carrying bonneted occupants down the side of a road may be quaint, but itís also dangerous for both horse and occupants. Because of the temperament and training of carriage horses, the actual number of accidents is far fewer. And, you have to consider the plight of performances horses. The public is generally uninformed with regard to the number of horses that are badly injured and die in sports like flat racing and steeplechasing, eventing, show jumping, and other Ďextremeí horse sports. Horses and people have horrible accidents everywhere.

Old Carriage Horses Go for Dog Meat
Whether a dead horse goes for dog meat or fertilizer, or buried with full honours and a gravestone is irrelevant. We need to use all resources responsibly and rendering is a wise use of resources. Far more relevant is how horses are treated when they are alive. Some carriage owners are mindful that their horses need turn out on regularly and a happy retirement and do the best they can to provide both. Itís the rotten apples that taint the barrel.

Carriage Horses Breath Car Fumes
Pointing out the bad the fumes a horse must breathe is relevant. Their head carriage puts their faces at the level of a lot of exhaust. Horse lungs are delicate. But far more worrisome is the possibility of a horse slipping and injuring itself - somewhat mitigated by shoes with non-slip material on them, and the gradual effects of concussion that will cause joint problems over time.

I think itís fair to be concerned about carriage horses working in extreme hot or cold. Most of us would rather not see horses working in hot humid weather on sweltering city streets, or during Arctic-frigid cold. The heat actually the more worrisome condition.

Horses Never Get Green Grass and Adequate Rest
Green grass is rare for many horses, but the argument that the horses donít get adequate turnout may be valid. Ideally horses should get rotated so they arenít pounding the pavement every day. A roomy stall isnít exactly being locked in a closet, but it isnít a sunny pasture either. Unfortunately, money is a big obstacle to an operator owning double the number of horses they are actually using. And green pastures near major urban areas donít come cheap.

Can The Carriage Trade Be Done Right?
I think it is possible to run the carriage trade so that it takes the best possible care of the horses and is safe and enjoyable for the humans involved. First, horses need to travel in low traffic areas. Unfortunately, these arenít always the places tourists want to see. Horses should be rotated regularly, so that they get pasture and recovery time. Every consideration should be given to shoeing and leg support to reduce the effects of standing and travelling on hard surfaces.Carriage horses should be banned from the streets during extremes in weather. Standards of stabling need to be improved. These are just a few of the things that could be done to make the carriage trade better, but unfortunately, the biggest obstacle is money.

What do you think?
 Related Horse News
Is it Time To End Horse Drawn Carriages in New York City
29th Jan 2014   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
I've had to spend some time in the city lately, and I can't say I've particularly enjoyed the experience. With its crowded sidewalks, bumper-to-bumper traffic, car exhaust and strange smells, potholes and streetcar tracks, flashin ...
Looking at the Arguments Against the Carriage Trade
5th Jun 2016   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
While I fundamentally agree that the time for the carriage trade in its present form is past, some of the arguments you see online against it donít make sense.The public often doesnít see horses in the same way Ďhorse peopleí do, ...
Horse Carriage Trade Update
7th Jun 2017   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
In Montreal, Canada, calls to end the carriage trade within the city have intensified. Two incidents during the first long weekend of the summer. In one, a horse fell, requiring the assistance of onlookers and a veterinarian to he ...
Horse Collapses at Sugar Shack Wagon Ride
25th Apr 2019   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Animal activists cry foul as video of a horse pulling a wagon load of tourists enjoying a day at a maple sugar bush fell. The Montreal SPCA is investigating and the contractor who ran the wagon ride at the sugar bush has suspende ...
Another Caleche Horse Collapses Weeks Before Ban
9th Nov 2019   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
CalŤche horses in the city of Montreal are again in the focus of animal rights activists. This time a horse slipped as it crossed a metal plate and ended up lying on its side in the street. Although the police found no abuse of th ...
Victoria BC Horse Carriage Ban
22nd Jun 2018   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
The rumblings about the carriage trade in Victoria have been ongoing for some time now. An incident last May has brought the business under harder scrutiny. Earlier this spring, two horses pulling a carriage fell on the street. A ...
Rescue Homes For Carriage Horses
3rd May 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
As of January 1, 2020, the carriage trade came to an end. As a result, the calache horses were given other jobs, or retired. One organization, A Horse Tales Rescue is providing homes for former carriage trade horses, helping them ...
Montreal Carriage Rides End
26th Jan 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
After years of controversy the city of Montreal, Quebec, caleches, the quaint carriage rides through the historic city are banned as of January 1, 2020. The tourist districts will no longer hear the familiar clip clop of hooves as ...
Savannah Carriage Rides in Extreme Heat
5th Jun 2019   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Like so many other cities and tourist areas around the world, Savannah, Georgia is grappling with issues surrounding carriage horses. Even in the hottest days of summer, Savannahís three carriage operators give tours through histo ...
Istanbul Tourist Carriage Horses In Dire Condition
9th Feb 2020   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
It often seems that tourism and horses is an unfortunate mix, especially when the offerings go unregulated. Such is the case in Istanbul, where carriage rides have come under scrutiny. Combined with a deadly virual outbreak, Istan ...
  View More PonyBox Related Horse Articles
 More News by Winniefield Park
🐎 Aggressive Horse Fine Under Saddle but Miserable on Ground Work
24th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Itís not unusual for a horse to be a joy under saddle but miserable to work with on the ground. This pony is 21 years old, and while heís a perfect childís pony while ridden, heís a menace to adults and children when handling him ...
👹 CreatureComforts Pushes Rare Breeds to Top of PonyBox
22nd May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
An effort by one breeder has highlighted the talents of a rare breed, placing several within the top 100 rankings. Leading the pack was 16-year-old Hungarian Warmblood mare CC Charlies Scam as she sat at the #1 ranked spot. With h ...
🔖 Equestrian 101 - Learning to Ride
19th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
If you think youíd like to learn to horseback ride, or are just getting started here are some great tips from a reporter whose family members are horse enthusiasts. Whether coach or rider, the agreement seems to be, the lessons l ...
🐎 Corolla Wild Horses Off To Rough Start in 2022
17th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
The foals being monitored by the Corolla Wild Horse Fund have had a rough start this spring. The first foal, a colt named Charlie unexpectedly died before he was a month old. He had appeared perfectly healthy. But the group had a ...
🌹 Rose To Prominence falls to Jack Flash in Fight for PonyBox Elite
15th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
PonyBox leader *Rose To Prominence was both #1 ranked horse and held the record for the highest jump until being usurped by 3Pxy *Jack Flash* who also held the top win streak with 2,078. ...
🏇🏼 Rich Strike Against All Odds Win of Kentucky Derby
14th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
ICYMI, the Kentucky Derby was held May 7th and the winner was a horse that ran because another horse was scratched and then started the race with 1-80 odds. Drone video shows how Rich Strike ran an impossible race to steal a win f ...
☁️ Dream Alliance by Ebony Friesians Record Jump at 105
8th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
* Dream Alliance * may have slipped from the top spot, usurped by challenger ?YouAreMySunshine but she still holds the record for the highest jump at 105 inches. The 15.3 hand Friesian mare foaled on March 6, 2022, and is bred and ...
🏇🏽 Santa Anita Park 32 Horse Deaths in Less Than 3 Years
7th May 2022   |   Horse Rescue and Abuse   |   Winniefield Park
Santa Anita Park has seen its share of bad publicity and it appears that is continuing after recording its fourth horse death since the beginning of 2022. Despite safety improvements to the track 17 horses died in 2020, and 12 in ...
  View All News by Winniefield Park
 
©2002 - 2022   PonyBox LLC Create Account Advertise Terms Privacy Contact Us
160 Members Online 271,296 Registered Members 3,052 News Articles 13,452,457 Unique News Article Views 323,687,093 Website Views