Horse Racing: Is it Cruel or Not?
 By Chris Antley Memorial   •   11th Jan 2010   •   10,402 views   •   17 comments
I have been a horse fanatic for almost 6 years now. I am very blessed to witness horse racings historical moments.

In 2007, I watched Rags to Riches beat the champion male Curlin in the Belmont Stakes. I also watched Curlin win the 2007 Breeders Cup Classic. In 2008, I saw Big Brown win the Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes. I also saw the undefeated Zenyatta win the Ladies Classic. And also, Curlin winning the Jockey Club Gold Cup becoming the #1 all-time North American money earner, being the only horse to win over 10 million in earnings. In 2009, I saw the long-shot Mine That Bird win the Kentucky Derby, the filly Rachel Alexandra win the Haskell and Preakness Stakes, and Summer Bird win the Belmont Stakes and the Travers Stakes. And I saw Zenyatta win the Breeders Cup Classic.

Also in 2009 I was able to go to a racetrack for my very first time. As a 16th birthday present I went to the Saratoga Racetrack. I got to see Kent Desormeaux, Calvin Borel, Johnny Velasquez, Edgar Prado, and more. I also got to meet Mine That Bird's trainer. I was able to get a picture with him and his autograph.

From 2007 to 2009, I have not only been able to witness historical moments, but sadly I have seen racing's tragedies. In 2007, I saw the European horse George Washington break down in the Breeders Cup Classic. In that year also, I followed the news with Barbaro after he broke down in the Preakness Stakes. In 2008, I watched the filly Eight Belles be put down after breaking down in the Kentucky Derby. And in the Belmont, I watched in horror and shock as I saw Big Brown be pulled up on the top of stretch. And still to this day I can hear the words of the track announcer as he called in disbelief, "And Big Brown has been eased at the top of the stretch." Again, in 2009, I witnessed tragedy. I saw Wanderin Boy being pulled up in the Cigar Mile and later put down.

I am not hear to brag about myself, but to tell you that all sports have their tragedies. Ever since I became involved in the Sport of Kings, I have heard people say that, "Horse racing is a cruel sport," or "They shouldn't be racing horses so young."

In my opinion, its not the sport that is cruel, it is the people within the sport that make it that way. Not everyone in horse racing is cruel and yes some things should be changed. Horse racing is learning from its mistakes. Because of the tragedies over the years, it has looked into more ways of making it safer for both horse and rider. For example: poly tracks and the ban of steroids.

Like I said before, every sport has its tragedies and every sport can be cruel. Some of you may think the using spurs or a whip/crop may be cruel. Those tools/aids weren't made to be cruel. They were made to help reinforce your natural aids. Unfortunitly, in the wrong hands, like someone who doesn't know how to use them properly, they can be cruel.

For example, a car may appear to be harmless, but once someone who has been drinking or if someone falls asleep behind the wheel, it can become dangerous.

What I am trying to say is that the sport itself isn't cruel, its people within it or a book, fork, butter knife, bottle, etc. can become dangerous depending on who is holding/using it.

Some of you may still think that horse racing is cruel. That is fine, its your opinion. I am not writing this to change your mind about it, but to open your mind to the fact that "everything" can be cruel and dangerous.

To tell you the truth, I believe that cross-country, harness racing, bull riding and steeplechasing is cruel and dangerous. However, I am not going to force my opinion on you and say that you are a bad person because you like or do that sport.

The tragedies of horse racing are very sad and tragic. Nothing can take away the horror of seeing a horse break down or get injured, but it happens...its life. Yes, it probably could of been prevented, but people have to learn from their mistakes. In my opinion, if it wasn't for Eight Belles, people wouldn't be looking into different kinds of surfaces for the tracks and banning steroids. If it wasn't for Barbaro, we wouldn't be finding a cure for laminitis.

So before you permanently marked down a sport as being cruel, think of all the good things it has to offer and how it is learning from its tragedies and mistakes.

So now it is up to you to determine if a sport is cruel or not.

I hope I made some sense in this article. I have a difficult time writing what I actually want to say.

This article wasn't written to start an argument, so please don't start one.

Thanks so much for reading!
Horse News More In This Category:  General      Horse News More From This Author:  Chris Antley Memorial
The big problem with racing is that they start training and riding the horses way too young, long before their bones have grown enough to be able to handle it. This is the #1 reason why we see so many horses break down. They ruin the horses long before they start racing them, just to save time, cause time is money. If they would wait 1 or 2 years longer, we wouldnt see as many accidents as we do now. I say, are the horses lives not more important than the sport, fame and money ? At the moment, sadly, obviously not.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,186 views
Suffolk Rose Stables  
I agree with Staffi. It is the only reason why I have ever conceded horse racing cruel. Though I know it is not. Then again I am looked at weird when I start Training and riding my horse at 2 years old. I agree with you as well Chris. With out the mistakes and people willing to learn to fix them it would be worse like it was long ago. I want to thank you for your point of view and I am glad you shared it.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,176 views
Chris Antley Memorial  MOD 
Staffi - You made a very good point. A lot of owners and trainers are in it just for the money and fame. However, there is just as many who are in it for the horses and their love for the sport. Secretariat's owner is a great example of that type of owner. During an interview with her about the new Secretariat movie coming out she said that she wants this movie to show everyone that it isn't for the money and fame. This sport is about the horses.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,199 views
Wanderin Boy Memorial  
Amazing article Chris ! You have points from each side, and facts to back up what you said. I agree with everything you have said.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,173 views
Not Cruel
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,213 views
Chris Antley Memorial  MOD 
You both made great points. I found an answer for your point about how their bones aren't fully developed. Bloodhorse wrote an article and has videos out about, "Losing the Iron Horse." They say that the horses today aren't as strong as they were years ago. In my opinion it is the breeders who are breeding fragile horses. Some breeders are breeding just for the speed and champions. They should put that aside and breed for the strength and durability. Here is the link to the video:
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,199 views
Apple Tree Farm  
I feel that it is cruel because they start traing at 2years old and there bones are not devolped enough. Also whipping them isn't fair they try there hardest. And when they are lame or not wanted any more they are sold on some for meat and others to homes but many are forever broken and why shoul this cruel sport be alowed if they did it to humans many people would have something to say.. I don't wish to start an argument but that is what i think and it will never change.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,196 views
I worked at both Pimlico and Laural Race Cource in Baltimore Md. for over 10yrs. but over all they have Vet care and food every day to where I see starved horses out in some ones field so it is just like any other sport and to be honest how many people have ridden their horse on a trail and their horse gets really hurt is that crule
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,216 views
Chris Antley Memorial  MOD 
Apple Tree - I fully respect your opinion and I understand why you feel that way. About the bones not being fully developed, look at the link I provided in my comment below yours. In my opinion, jockeys use the crop because since their stirrups are up higher they are unable to kick and ask them to go. Rose - Wow, 10 years. I agree with you. Racehorses, in my opinion, have the greatest care. They are constantly checked by a vet, even before races to make sure they are fit for racing(if not they are scratched), their groom is there 24/7 and they always have food to eat and plenty of exercise. Racehorses love running and they to love the excitement of it. An example is Zenyatta. She loves what she does and when the finish line comes, her ears are forward.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,199 views
Amazing! I have been waiting fot this, just a few months ago I was talking to a friend and I said "Do you like the racehorse Rachel Alexandra?" They replied "Horse racing is cruel." I don't see why they said that they've never seen a race or they think it's cruel to because the jockeys have crops. Thank you for posting this Chris.
  Jan 11, 2010  •  5,178 views
Chris Antley Memorial  MOD 
Black Hauraki - Wow, you made an outstanding point. I have never thought of it that way.
  Jan 13, 2010  •  5,199 views
The reason for all the tbs breaking down is because they are so young and their bones arnt fully developed yet. They race standardbreds at 3 instead of 2 and they end up being able to race longer. And i think that horse racing is crule because most of the race horse owners run the horses down until they are done then send them to the slaughter house. And that happens alot with stbs to because ppl think that they arnt good for anything but racing.
  Jan 14, 2010  •  5,192 views
Trial and error is the key to everything. I am against things that the whole perpose of the sport or whatever it may be is to ingure somebody or something. Boxing, for example, I'm not a fan of. The goal is to knock eachother out. While the goal in racing is to run. Nobody's intentions were "Let's find a track that Ruffian or Barbaro will hurt themselves on". Also, whether the horse is young or old, accidents will happen. You can't bubble wrap the world. Driving a car and you lose control and you pop a tire. Have to desetroy your car. When you get a new car, you learn from your mistake and you take percautions. Same with racing. Ridings dangerous, being around horses can be dangerous, flyings dangerous, drivings dangerous but it's something we do anyway. Do we give four year olds a kitchen knife, no, but do we never let them use one when they're fourty? Anyway, got carried away, my point:Life happens.
  Jan 15, 2010  •  5,224 views
Chris Antley Memorial  MOD 
Ashtashley - I am glad you got carried away. What you said in that little paragraph, I tried to say in my article. Like I said in my article, I have trouble writing what I actually want to say. I love the point you made. Haha, you should of wrote this article for me. xD
  Jan 16, 2010  •  5,199 views
i think that horse racing is over rated, and hurts the horse!!
  Jan 16, 2010  •  5,207 views
Pink Pony  
i don't think racing is cruel but many people say horses do it for fun but the truth is that they do it because they think their is something to run from, in the wild the slowest horse would be the one the predetor caught. but its not cruel and the horses don't seem upset by it so i don't think its that bad.
  Jan 23, 2011  •  5,199 views
Little Bitty Farm  
Great article!
  23 days ago  •  5,201 views
 More News by Chris Antley Memorial
Jockey With Stuttering Disorder Wins On Great Communicator
27th Jun 2011   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
The Breeders Cup is the World Series of horse racing. The one people remember the most is the Breeders Cup Classic because the best from the best from around the world meet up in that one race to determine who the best is. No ...
How To Become Popular On Ponybox
7th Mar 2011   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
Lucy decides to join Ponybox. She already figured everything out and is now on the forums meeting all the other players and joining in on their discussions. Two weeks go by and she still views herself as a new player. She re ...
The Coveted Triple Crown
4th Feb 2011   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
Winning the Triple Crown of Thoroughbred Racing is considered the greatest accomplishment of a Thoroughbred racehorse. The Triple Crown consists of the Kentucky Derby, Preakness Stakes, and the Belmont Stakes. One might think th ...
Excerpt From My Book: Phillipines 4:13
23rd Jan 2011   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
This is an excerpt from the introduction to my book, “Philippines 4:13.” This book is the story of my life as a young teenager to my life now, currently in training to become a jockey. Being a jockey is one of the easiest thing ...
Taking The Dressage World By Storm
10th Jan 2011   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
For a long time I always looked at Dressage as a boring form of riding with no excitement. Then after I came across a Youtube video of a black 17.1 hand Dutch Warmblood stallion, the way I looked at Dressage changed. The horse’s ...
Nearing the Two Year Mark on Ponybox
6th Jan 2011   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
Almost two years ago on January 28, 2009, I came across Ponybox while searching for horse games online. Ever since that moment when I clicked, “Create Account” Ponybox has been my “home.” Ever since the moment I joined my barn ...
Realistic Horse Digi Tutorial
21st Dec 2010   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
So many people on Morgan Ponybox messaged me asking if I could make a tutorial for digitals. So after many months of it is. Also, if you have any suggestions for tutorials just message me on here or on Morgan at C ...
AntMan Chris Antley - A Decade Later
12th Dec 2010   |   General   |   Chris Antley Memorial
Chris Antley was born on January 6, 1966 in South Carolina. He was an insecure kid, who was too small to make the football team. He fell into work at a stable in the town of Elloree, not because he knew anything about horses. He ...
  View All News by Chris Antley Memorial
©2002 - 2020   PonyBox LLC Create Account Terms & Conditions Privacy Contact Us
192 Members Online 265,328 Registered Members 2,714 News Articles 11,541,832 Unique News Article Views 274,578,285 Website Views